| PAST MASTERS | |
| Carroll E. Pennsinger | 1962 |
| Arthur C. Warnick, Jr. | 1963 |
| Howard B. Zody | 1974 |
| Jack T. Duffey | 1978 |
| Melvin G Harbaugh, Jr. | 1981 |
| Roger A. Hahn | 1982 |
| C. Mark Recard | 1986 |
| Thomas E. Wynkoop | 1989 |
| John L. Stains, PDDGM | 1990 |
| James C. Recard | 1991 |
| Robert W. Nelson, Jr. | 1992 |
| Jeffrey B. Geesaman | 1994 |
| John E. N. Blair | 1995 |
| Dennis R. McClanahan | 1996 |
| D. Lloyd Reicard II | 1998 |
| Bradley D Greenawalt | 1999 |
| Michael A. Selman, Sr. | 2000 |
| Tracy G. Hight | 2001 |
| Anthoy A. Haugh | 2002 |
| Anthoy A. Haugh | 2003 |
| D. Lamar Sease | 2004 |
| William W. Wepking | 2005 |
| Jeffrey B. Geesaman | 2006 |
| Jeremy A. Bowersox | 2007 |
| Jason B. Stains | 2008 |
| William W. Wepking | 2009 |
| Joel D. Klimoski | 2010 |
| Anthoy A. Haugh | 2011 |
| Dennis R. McClanahan | 2012 |
| Michael A. Ramsay | 2013 |
| Darryll C. Forney Sr. | 2014 |
| Anthony M. Mullins | 2015 |
| John E. Shaffer | 2016 |
| Lawrence C. Gates | 2017 |
| C. Edward Bortzfield | 2018 |
| C. Edward Bortzfield | 2019 |
| Zachary L. Wilhide | 2020 |
| Henry A. Martin | 2021 |
| Joshua P. Brown | 2022 |
| DECEASED PAST MASTERS | |
| Samuel R. Frantz | 1891 |
| Albert J. Harbaugh | 1892 |
| Samuel C. Plank | 1893 |
| Jacob H. Stoner | 1895 |
| Aaron Werner | 1896 |
| John Calvin Criswell | 1897 |
| John Calvin Criswell | 1898 |
| Charles B. Clayton | 1899 |
| Cecil B. McKnown | 1900 |
| John Calvin Criswell | 1901 |
| Frank W. Benedict | 1902 |
| Addison Goodfellow | 1903 |
| Frank B. Hershey | 1904 |
| John H. Bower | 1905 |
| Watson C. Stoner | 1906 |
| Joseph R. Hutchison, Jr. | 1907 |
| Jaes C. Lochbaum | 1908 |
| A. Stewart Etter | 1909 |
| Ulysses Grant Bishop | 1910 |
| Franklin J. W. Horich | 1911 |
| Alvin H. Baer | 1912 |
| Samuel F. Newman | 1913 |
| Emory T. Bitner | 1914 |
| Emry G. Heefner | 1915 |
| J. Lesley McCleary | 1916 |
| Arthur B. Frantz | 1917 |
| Albert A. Detwiler | 1918 |
| Robert R. Arthur | 1919 |
| J. Clair McCullough | 1920 |
| J. Garfield Miller | 1921 |
| Luther J. Wiekert | 1922 |
| Samuel S. Shoemaker | 1923 |
| Joseph E. Guy | 1924 |
| J. Franklin Kercheval | 1926 |
| Harry E. D. Gray | 1927 |
| Luther H. Yingling | 1928 |
| Jesse G. Beard | 1929 |
| George L. McCleaf | 1931 |
| Chester E. Adams | 1932 |
| A. Lambert Oller, Jr. | 1933 |
| Faber W. Heefner | 1934 |
| Claude B. Geesaman | 1935 |
| William B. Miller | 1936 |
| James W. McKnown | 1937 |
| Roy H. baker | 1938 |
| Walter W. Strite | 1939 |
| William O. Kline | 1940 |
| R. Eugene Arthur | 1941 |
| John Welty Jr. | 1942 |
| Harper M. Miller | 1943 |
| Richard R. Arthur | 1944 |
| Donald W. Mort | 1945 |
| D. Carroll Peters | 1946 |
| James E. Seigrist | 1947 |
| Audrey F. Stouffer | 1948 |
| Donald S. Fitz | 1949 |
| Edward C. Miller Sr. | 1950 |
| Earl O. Moore | 1951 |
| Joseph O. Berkheimer | 1952 |
| Raymond E. Barnhart | 1953 |
| Harry A. Graham | 1954 |
| William H. Arthur | 1955 |
| Robet E. Carson | 1956 |
| C. Brandt Singer | 1957 |
| Harry M. Wallace, Jr. | 1958 |
| Charles D. Wink | 1959 |
| Elmer E. Smith | 1960 |
| Staat T. Stymiest | 1961 |
| H. Max Snowberger | 1964 |
| C. Wayne Pittman | 1965 |
| Milton L. Cline | 1966 |
| John C. Verdier | 1967 |
| Charles W. Mcintire | 1968 |
| Mark H. McFerren | 1969 |
| Clarence D. Smith | 1970 |
| Robert D. Helm | 1971 |
| Chauncey R. Blubaugh, Jr. | 1972 |
| Warren E. Tomlinson | 1973 |
| DeWayne McAninch | 1975 |
| Joseph L. Bock | 1976 |
| Frank J. Lenfestey | 1977 |
| Jack N. Rodgers | 1979 |
| Van L. Eyer | 1980 |
| Edgar S. Wolfkill, Jr. | 1983 |
| Randall W. Sprenkle | 1984 |
| Richard E. Mathias | 1985 |
| William G. Adams, Jr. | 1987 |
| Louie D. Martin | 1988 |
| Gerald E. Alleman | 1993 |
| James C. Valentine | 1997 |
Free and Accepted Masons Constituted May 22, 1891